john3859
Dołączył: 25 Sty 2011
Posty: 1639
Przeczytał: 0 tematów
Ostrzeżeń: 0/5 Skąd: England
|
Wysłany: Śro 18:21, 09 Mar 2011 Temat postu: "yourcriticismofmyexperimentisinvalid |
|
|
tionmaybethoroughlyembeddedinan
emotionalcontextandsothemselvesbecomeemotional.Consideranangry
microbiologist'sjudgmentswhichmightseemtobewhollyconcernedwithmicrobiology
andmethodology("yourcriticismofmyexperimentisinvalid [link widoczny dla zalogowanych]!").Itisnotclearthatsuch
judgmentsshouldbetreatedonlyasthecausalbackgroundoftheangerratherthanas
partofit.Suchjudgmentsalonearenotanemotionbutwhatmakesthemofparticular
significancetoemotionisthecontextofotherjudgmentswhichwemightsummarizeas
thejudgmentthatthisisamatterofurgentpersonalimportance.Butjudgingitisa
matterofurgentpersonalimportancealoneisnotenoughtoconstituteanemotion
either;anemotionalsoneedsitsspecificcontent(oftensummedupastheideathat
emotionsare"intentional")suchasthatprovidedbythejudgmentthatJonesis
offensiveorbythejudgmentthatthecriticismoftheexperimentisinvalid.Weshould
notassumethatthejudgmentthatthecriticismoftheexperimentisinvalid.Weshould
notassumethatthejudgmentsconstitutinganemotionmustallhavesome
characteristiccontentorinthemselvesbeparticularlyemotional.Anemotionistheentire
systemofjudgmentsandthejudgmentsthatconstitutetheemotionareemotionalby
virtueoftheirplaceinthatsystem.
Thestandardobjection��thatonecanmakethesamejudgmentswithout
emotion��ismoreofastrategicmaneuveryilai:
[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]
[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]
[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]
http://www.pokemont.fora.pl/arena-ognia,8/on-the-makaloa-mat-londonjack-publishedaankoc,20800.html#22652
Post został pochwalony 0 razy
|
|